I have read enough novels in The Destroyer series to know that its satire can not only be politically incorrect, but that its predominant political viewpoint is an ultra-conservative one. I have no problem with either, really. I think the former is fundamentally necessary, as boundaries should always be pushed, sensibilities offended, toes squashed and some noses tweaked. As for the latter, it is healthy to be challenged and I am old enough, and have grown wise enough, to know that it is oft times better to simply agree to disagree, and just walk away. As long as I am entertained, it is all good; and The Destroyer series is very entertaining. Even when it pushes the boundaries to the breaking point and crosses into territory that can offend; and that is precisely what happens in Mugger Blood
.
To be blunt, the book is racist.
Whether or not the authors (and series creators) Warren Murphy and Richard Sapir are racist themselves is a debate for people who actually know (in the case of the late Richard Sapir, knew) them. Art has a way of getting away from its creator(s) and becoming something that is both a representation of its creator(s) and something that is completely and utterly unlike its creator(s).
The edition that I read has an introduction by Murphy that briefly touches on the novel's possible genesis and how, after a lengthy list of all the ethnic groups that had been satirized or lampooned in the twenty-nine books that preceded Mugger Blood
, that it was this particular book that some readers complained about. Chiun himself then chimes in, dismissing the claims of racism and then explaining that all races are inferior to Koreans, and that all Koreans are inferior to the residents of the city of Sinanju, and that even the residents of Sinanju are inferior to the residents of the House of Sinanju.
Come to think of it, all are inferior to the single most glorious resident of the House of Sinanju. All hail the Master of Sinanju!
While the one-two punch of serious discussion and satirical dismissal of the allegations of racism show that the authors have, at the very least, taken the comments about Mugger Blood
seriously, by the midpoint of the novel, I was wincing, shaking my head and thinking/muttering, "Mythical-God, is this book racist!"
The set-up is straight forward, an elderly German woman is tortured to death in her Bronx home. Well, there has to be some kind of brutal atrocity to capture the attention of CURE and to get Remo's ire up, yes? Afterward, the building the unfortunate woman had been living in is demolished and all the rubble carted away for examination by the CIA. Smitty then sends Remo and Chiun into the Bronx to find the alleged "super-weapon" that the Super Powers That Be believe to have been hidden inside the woman's home. Also sneaking around are some Russian agents, one of which seems to be a dry run for the gun happy vigilante in Bay City Blast
. So far, so good. In this area alone the book is a typical Cold War era Destroyer novel.
But then the corrupt Reverend Josiah Wadson (a parody of Al Sharpton) and the various street gangs that have taken over the Bronx and turned it into what looks like a bombed out war zone arrive to muddy the narrative waters with politically incorrect satire and biting social commentary. That there were valid points to be found in both the satire and commentary is beside the point, for the racial stereotyping is so broad, and the lack of counterbalance so notably absent, that it seems as if all African-Americans are being made to appear as if they are nothing more than sub-literate animals that label any and all that confront or question their behavior as racist. If Murphy and Sapir had taken a moment to show one person struggling to overcome the toxic war zone that the Bronx had become (to get an idea of just how bad it was, go out and rent the films Wolfen
and Fort Apache, The Bronx
, both were set and filmed in and around the kind of neighborhood that Mugger Blood
takes place) then the book would not have left such a sour taste in my mouth. But Murphy and Sapir did not do that, and Mugger Blood
is a lesser reading experience because of it.
Recent Comments